STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — The final search in our series this year was, fittingly, for the best regular slice in town.

The latest Best of Staten Island 2025 category kicked off earlier this month by asking readers to nominate the best cheese pizza that could be found across Staten Island.

Fifty-five pizzerias were nominated on our social pages for the Best of Plain Pizza 2025 contest. Then, the voting began, and our winners were determined.

The top three vote-getters were Napoli Pizza in Sunnyside , Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe in Port Richmond and Brother’s Pizzeria in Port Richmond.

The Advance/SILive.com recently visited each pizzeria to find out why our readers chose each one to order their cheese pizzas.

Napoli Pizzeria, 1206 Victory Blvd. in Sunnyside & 97 Lincoln Ave. in Grant C

See Full Page